| Platinum | Scarpetta Italian Eatery |
| Gold | Pranzo Italiano |
| Silver | Il Chianti Restaurant |
| Bronze | Chianti Willow Park |
| Top Pick | Bonterra Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Cardinale |
| Top Pick | Il Centro |
| Top Pick | Italian Centre Shop |
| Top Pick | Noto Gelato |
| Top Pick | The Italian Store |