| Platinum | Village Ice Cream |
| Gold | Made by Marcus |
| Silver | My Favorite Ice Cream Shoppe |
| Bronze | Confetti |
| Top Pick | Abbey’s Creations |
| Top Pick | Amato Gelato |
| Top Pick | Dairy Queen |
| Top Pick | Holy Cow Gelato and Donuts |
| Top Pick | LICS - Leavitt's Ice Cream Shop |
| Top Pick | Yogen Früz |